Training or work? Unpaid interns want companies to pay up

There’s a growing backlash against unpaid internships that some say aren’t providing the training promised. The movement is emboldened by a spate of recent court decisions.
 
Unpaid interns agree to work free in exchange for training and job prospects, but a growing number of them say employers aren’t living up to their side of the bargain.
In recent months, former interns in the U.S. have won several high-profile lawsuits for back wages, spurring a growing backlash here in Canada.
Jainna Patel, 24, a math and statistics graduate from McMaster University, filed a federal labour complaint against Bell Mobility after spending five weeks in its Professional Management Program (PMP) in Mississauga.
In response, Human Resources Development Canada sent a letter to Bell, requesting it either pay Patel’s back wages or contest the complaint she filed. The company had until July 9th to file its response.
Video
A Bell spokesperson told the Toronto Star that their program is not only legal, but one of the best internships in the country.
In the year since Patel first filed her complaint she hasn’t heard from Bell, but remains hopeful because interns across North America have been winning cases like hers.
Last month, two unpaid interns working on the Oscar-winning film Black Swan successfully sued Fox Searchlight pictures. A New York district judge ordered the film production company to pay back wages because the interns did the same work as regular employees, provided value to the company and performed low-level tasks that didn’t require any specialized training. Fox is appealing the ruling.
Shortly after the decision, interns at Gawker, an American celebrity website, also filed a suit for unpaid wages.
Here in Canada, interns are also starting to file complaints — and win. In 2012, Kyle Iannuzzi was awarded almost $1,000 in back wages from Platinum Events Group in what he believes was the first successful complaint against a company for an unpaid internship in Ontario.
Unpaid internships have long been standard in journalism, entertainment and publishing. CBC, which has reported on Patel’s complaint, runs a six-week unpaid internship program, but only takes students currently enrolled in a journalism program. Rogers Media runs paid and unpaid internship programs and accepts people who aren’t enrolled in post-secondary education.
While there are no reliable statistics, internships appear to have spread to virtually every sector of the economy.
Federal Liberal leader Justin Trudeau joined the growing chorus of criticism last month, decrying a situation where “you can’t get a job without getting experience; you can’t get experience without getting a job.”
“These unpaid internship . . . unfortunately are not helping individuals or our economy,” he said. “I think we need to look at stronger oversight and enforcing the regulations that exist.”
Labour laws here differ from those in the U.S., but determining the legality of unpaid internships is especially difficult north of the border because both Canada’s and Ontario’s employment laws don’t directly address the issue.
“The bottom line is, if what is being done for the ‘employer’ looks like work, then it should be compensated as work,” said Sean Bawden, an Ottawa-based labour lawyer who writes a blog on employment issues.
Bell Mobility says its Professional Management Program employs 300 unpaid interns at a dedicated campus in Mississauga in a variety of tasks including marketing and data analytics. While it accepts current post-secondary students, the program requires “associates” to work full time.
Bell spokesperson Albert Lee would not comment directly on Patel’s case, but said the PMP program provides an opportunity for those with little experience to learn the tools of the trade.
“It’s important to note that this is a learning program — participants do not replace any Bell employees, and their work doesn’t support or benefit any of Bell’s business operations,” he wrote in an email. “Many companies have intern training programs (the estimate is about 300,000 interns a year in Canada) . . . We think the learning environment and calibre of the volunteer management that support the program make it one of the best.”
Patel’s labour complaint tells a different story. She writes that she was lured in with promises of gaining valuable training for which she was willing to forgo pay. Once there, she spent long hours transcribing video, conducting telephone surveys and filling in spreadsheets, she alleges in the complaint, and was regularly asked to stay as late as midnight.
After raising concerns that she was doing menial tasks and receiving little training, Patel quit the internship and filed a labour complaint with the federal government.
“I looked up the laws and felt as if the work we were doing was that of a paid employee,” Patel wrote.
Patel has asked for just under $2,500 in wages, overtime and vacation pay. HRDC wouldn’t comment on her case, citing confidentiality concerns.
The Canada Labour Code does not explicitly treat internships, but most employers say they are a form of training that is exempted from payment. The law on whether training must be compensated is far from clear.
A note interpreting whether training hours must be paid posted to HRDC’s website states that, “training initiated on the volition of the employee or developmental voluntary training which prepares the employee for another job does not constitute hours of work.”
The document goes on to draw a line between short-term and long-term training, “where the candidate is learning and performing certain aspects of the job.”
“In this latter situation, where a de facto employment relationship has been established, the time constitutes hours of work,” where “the employee is entitled to be paid at the regular rate of wages,” says the note, written by RenĂ©e Godmer, executive co-ordinator of HRDC’s Labour Program.
This note is dated and doesn’t carry the same legal weight of a statute or a regulation, said labour lawyer Bawden.
Despite the ongoing grievance, Patel is determined to stay positive. She’s found paid work and even works a second job on Saturdays.
Patel still lists the PMP on her resume and even received a job interview from Bell after having left the program.
She doesn’t object to unpaid internships per se and hopes her complaint will make the PMP a better experience for future associates.

Since filing her complaint, Patel says people have congratulated her for being go gutsy — an attitude that worries her.
“We are protected by laws, and it is important to educate ourselves with these laws,” she said. “I do not believe I did anything extraordinary, I simply questioned the work I was doing and filed a claim to have it be reviewed.”

Originally published at http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2013/07/22/training_or_work_unpaid_interns_want_companies_to_pay_up.html.

TORONTO CAREER FAIR - FRIDAY OCTOBER 4 AT ROGERS CENTRE IN TORONTO


 
 

The Toronto Career Fair - October 4th at the Rogers Centre in Toronto.


Presented by TorontoJobs.ca in partnership with the Toronto Argonauts Football Club, this is the premiere Job and Career Event in the Greater Toronto Area.


Interested in attending?  Register now at http://ow.ly/mbkDj.


Interested in Exhibiting?  Get information at http://ow.ly/nnlDk or email marc.belaiche@torontojobs.ca.
 
 

UPDATE ON TALES FROM THE RECRUITER BOOK!

tales from the recruiter book cover

I wanted to give you a few quick updates about the new "Tales from the Recruiter - A Canadian Recruiter's Perspective on How to Get That Perfect Job".
 
1. We did have some delays in getting the hard copy books but they will be delivered to our office soon and your book will either be mailed or available for pick up at our office soon (depending on how you ordered it). 
 
2. We are posting updates on the book to the website at www.TalesfromtheRecruiter.ca website and more updates will be available soon.
 
3. This fall should be very busy with various book events, presentations, etc. throughout the Greater Toronto Area.
 
4. There is a free "Tales from the Recruiter" webinar available for you and/or anyone else you think might be interested on September 25th.  The webinar will give you stories of things that have happened in my recruiting career and things you should avoid/be aware of in your job search. You can find out more details and register at http://tinyurl.com/lghwbkj.  Can't make it at that time?  You can register and listen/watch the webinar at a time that's convenient for you.
 
5. The book is also available for download/purchase through Amazon (see http://tinyurl.com/k4gracf) and will soon be available for download/purchase through Kobo.
 
6. Above you'll also see the cover of the book.

I'm excited for you to both get the book and read it!  The book has taken close to 3 years to get to this point.  Send me your feedback when you do get a chance to read it and feel free to pass the book on to others.  If you'd like more copies of the book please don't hesitate to ask me about it!

thanks,

Marc Belaiche, CPA, CA
President
TorontoJobs.ca
Author of "Tales from the Recruiter"

160 Traders Boulevard East
Suite# 101, Mississauga, Ontario
L4Z 3K7
Phone: 905-566-JOBS (905-566-5627of_the_skype_highlightingd_of_the_skype_highlighting) x2873
Fax: 905-566-1179
Cell: 905-783-1777 begin_of_the_skype_highlighting 
Toll Free: 1-866-486-JOBSd_of_the_skype_highlighting (1-866-486-5627 begin_of_the_skype_highlighting)

RESUME ACCESS ON TORONTOJOBS.CA DISCOUNTED UNTIL JULY 31, 2013


If you are unable to view this email please click here.

TorontoJobs.ca
The Local Connection to Qualified Candidates
Save up to $150 on Resume Access for a Limited Time Only!
Click to Purchase
To speak with one of our dedicated Account Executives in regards to your staffing needs please call (905) 566-JOBS (5627)
or email
sales@TorontoJobs.ca.
Conditions: HST charges apply – Booking deadline is July 31, 2013 – Offer cannot be used in conjunction with any other offers – Other conditions may apply.
To View Our Full Media Kit Please Click Here.
TorontoJobs.ca has been dedicated to helping companies find candidates for their positions within the Greater Toronto Area since 2002. With millions of hits to our website each month, thousands of resumes in our database and our full-service Recruitment Division, TorontoJobs.ca can help you find candidates for your company based on your specific hiring requirements.

Why Take a Vacation?

Startup life is about passion, drive, hustle, late nights, early mornings and responsibility, right?

Right. Business owners feel the pressure of what needs to be done right now, so vacation falls into second place in the priority line. Or even third or fourth… Who can think about enjoying time at the beach when you could be growing your business. Where does vacation time fit in, and is it really that important?

Let’s talk about what happens if you don’t take some time out.

It’s not a pretty picture. Poor health, loss of focus, loss of passion, relationship issues, unhappiness, and that’s just to begin with. Not taking a break can contribute to adrenal fatigue, or ‘burnout’, with symptoms of fatigue and weakness, skin problems, depression, poor memory, and much more. The adrenal glands sit on top of the kidneys and secrete stress hormones (cortisol). They become taxed if not given a break. Infrequent vacationing is also associated with an increased risk of heart attack and heart disease. Pretty scary stuff.

But it’s not even all about your health. Taking breaks can actually help your startup

Former NASA scientists found that vacationers experienced an 82% increase in job performance post-trip. Stepping away from the screen, getting distance, taking a mental break, refreshing and rejuvenating the mind all aids productivity. Stefan Sagmeister knows all about the power of time off. Vacations can lead to creative bursts that you wouldn’t normally have when sitting in your office. New places = new thoughts. Old problems become new solutions. Greater perspective means greater success. And business owners who demonstrate a good example for their employees will ultimately inspire an overall increase in productivity and positive morale.

I know you all know it makes sense. But what if you really can’t take all that time away?

‘Micro-vacations’ are popular. Taking 2-3 days away to relax could be all you need. Maybe even a 1-day “stay-cation” with family or friends, or time at a retreat for a guaranteed change of pace. These are all good, although not as beneficial as a longer vacation. Know your business and take time when there are naturally slow times.

If you really, really can’t take a day away, then learning to manage stress in your day-to-day routine can make all the difference. Build ‘me-time’ into your schedule, take regular walks, exercise, meditate, practise yoga and other stress management techniques, or enforce a no “screen time” period to get your head out of the tech buzz. Even something as simple as taking short breaks throughout the day, say 15 minutes every 2 hours, can drastically improve concentration and productivity. Who’s up for #startuprecess?

So what we’re really saying is there are no excuses

Drop the unhealthy guilt. Make your health a priority and your business will thrive. Now go and book your vacation – doctor’s orders!

Article By: Helen Hayward. Article Originally Posted: http://www.startupcan.ca/2013/07/12/take-a-vacation-startupchats-recap/

What Do Your Best Customers Smell Like?

If information is power, how much do you know about your customers? Try this quiz.
1. Who are your three best customers?
2. Why do they do business with you?
3. What is their competitive edge?
4. What are their greatest challenges?
5. Who are their chief competitors?
6. What significant trends are impacting their industries?
7. What do your best customers have in common?

Why are each of these questions and the answers important to you? If you want to keep your best customers and find more like them read on.

1 Who are your best customers?
How do you define 'best'? Is it the one who paid you the most money this year, the one who has paid you the most over the last few years or the one who provides steady business, pays promptly and is easy to service? You decide. You might need to create a few categories of best and deal with each differently. However you define best, establish your criteria then measure it regularly. Know who your best are and what they're doing. Treat them special. Stay informed and keep them informed. Stay in contact with them more often.

2 Why do they do business with you?
Stop patting yourself on the back and claiming that they are smart enough to pick you. Maybe that's true. But don't assume. Forget surveys; ask them directly, over coffee or lunch, "Tell me why you selected my company as your supplier?" Follow up with, "I am always trying to improve my service, and I want to ensure I don't make the wrong changes. So if there is one thing that I should not change what is that?" You might be surprised by their answer.

3 What is their competitive edge?
Would you do business with your best customers? After you ask them why they do business with you, ask "Why do your best customers do business with you?" Watch their reaction at your interest in them. If you know their competitive edge then you can demonstrate how your company can help them with that important edge. You can also offer them ideas to help achieve and promote that edge. They will love you for it.

4 What are their greatest challenges?
Is it competition, staff, or finding time to relax? If they don't want to tell you then back off. Likely they will be only too happy to share their concerns with a trusted colleague. Listen and don't try to solve their problem unless that is your area of specialty. Ask them how they are approaching this challenge. You will learn more about them in understanding how they think. You may be able to recommend a book, seminar, or associate who specializes in that challenge. Or you may be able to help them directly by adapting your service to help. If you can help your customers with the ghosts that keep them awake at night, you will become invaluable.

5 Who are their chief competitors?
If you know whom they see as their chief competition you gain insight in to how they position themselves. Are they the market dominator or the underdog? Each will have entirely different corporate cultures, styles and needs. You will market to them differently.

You also need to decide if and how you will deal with the key competitors to your best customers. It will depend on the nature of your business and the level of trust and confidentiality needed to maintain good customer relationships. If you are tempted to sell to their competition remember that the surest way to create allies is to have a common enemy.

6 What significant trends are impacting their industries?
Be aware of threats to your customers' viability and discover new opportunities for your business. How is their industry changing? How will they do business in one, three and five years? And how will you fit into that?

If you are aware of these trends then more news about them tend to grab your attention when you read the news or talk to others. You might clip and send your customer an article that talks about the trends. Your customer will appreciate your interest. When you market your product you may explain how it protects them from a negative trend or takes advantage of a positive trend.

7 What do your best customers have in common?
If you want more 'best customers' then know how to find them. Describe your best customers and post it on your office wall. It's like a wanted poster for good customers. If you know what you are looking for you are more likely to find it.

Think about how a hunter tracks their prey. They learn the habits, smells, likes and dislikes. You can do the same to find your big game. Here is a sampling of the information you might collect about your best customers; clubs and associations of which they are members, where they live, what they read, their education, special interests, sports and hobbies, recreation, demographics & ethno graphics, etc.

You can do two things with this information. Direct your marketing to these groups or places. It is like fishing. Discover where to catch the best fish and concentrate your efforts in those places. Find where you will catch the best customers and concentrate your marketing there.

Secondly ask your best customers to refer you to others like them in their groups. We prefer to do business with others who are like us. These referrals have greater weight and it helps you catch the customers you want.

Sharpen your nose and happy hunting.


George Torok is co-author of the national bestseller, "Secrets of Power Marketing", the first Canadian guide to personal marketing. Get your free copy of “50 Power Marketing Ideas at www.PowerMarketing.ca



IMPORTANCE OF DISCONNECTING WHILE ON VACATION



For Immediate Release: Friday, July 12, 2013

Importance of Disconnecting While on Vacation

Toronto, ON. – With Summer in full-swing, it shouldn’t be surprising that 55 per cent of Canadians plan on taking a vacation over the next couple months; what is surprising is that according to a recent online poll, 58 per cent of Canadians work while on vacation. A recent survey found that 18 per cent of Canadian workers report that their job is “highly stressful.” Chronic stress can lead to burnout and can worsen existing mental health problems or physical disability, the research warns.

This season, avoid burning-out and make sure to check out of the office and into some relaxation. TorontoJobs.ca has compiled a list of tips for disconnecting from the office and learning to enjoy while on vacation. Whatever your plans are, take time to relax and have a safe holiday!

5 Tips for Disconnecting from the Office While on Vacation:

  1. Make your absence as easy as possible for your colleagues. Communicate with all team members about what is require of them and what must be handled while covering a vacation. Be sure to clarify all points and walk them through any tasks that are new to them. Leave detailed instructions!
  2. Set and stick to out of office messages. Don’t send mixed signals by having a clear out of off message turned on, but then responding to emails. If claiming inaccessibility, stay that way. Management’s vacation behaviour sets the tone for the office, so be sure to lead by example.
  3. Write it down. If caught thinking about work while on vacation, make a note about it and get back to enjoying the time off. Unless the item is critical, it can wait until the vacation is over.
  4. Leave space in the calendar. Make sure to leave the day before and the day after open in the calendar. Try not to book meetings etc. and use these days depart with confidence and time to deal with any unforeseen problems when upon return.
  5. Ditch the phone. If all else fails, avoid temptation by leaving the phone at home or locking it away while on vacation. Be careful or a disgruntled family member might end up disposing of the phone at the bottom of a lake!
Please feel free to re-print this article giving credit to TorontoJobs.ca.